• About F & S
  • Our Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
      • litigateLitigation Services
      • REGRegulatory Matters
      • Commercial Transactions
      • Labor & Employment
      • General Counsel Service
      • Government & Passenger Rail
    • Close
  • Our Clients
  • Alerts & Analysis
  • About F & S
  • Our Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
      • litigateLitigation Services
      • REGRegulatory Matters
      • Commercial Transactions
      • Labor & Employment
      • General Counsel Service
      • Government & Passenger Rail
    • Close
  • Our Clients
  • Alerts & Analysis

Appellate Court Rules a Handling Carrier Agreement with no Termination Clause is Terminable at Will Upon Reasonable Notice Under IL Law

  • On January 14, 2020

Michael J. Barron

On January 3, 2020, the US Court of Appeals for the 5th Cir issued an important opinion on contract rights under Illinois law, and set precedent for other states faced with interpreting if and how parties may terminate a contract of perpetual duration.  In this case, a Class I railroad sold a line to a Class III railroad. The purchase agreement included terms whereby the Class III would serve as a handling carrier for the Class I.  The agreement had no termination date and no interline pricing authority for the Class III carrier for traffic that originated or terminated on its line.  After two decades, this arrangement was creating significant economic harm for the Class III.  The Class III, relying on a principle of Illinois law that says contracts with no termination date can be terminated at will by either party after reasonable time has passed, served notice that it was canceling the handling line agreement and moving to control all pricing and rates on its line.  The Class I sued the Class III.  The trial court agreed with the Class I and found the Class III had breached the agreement. But on appeal the 5th Circuit reversed and entered judgment for the Class III carrier finding the handling line agreement had no further force or effect and that its lack of a termination provision brought it squarely within the principle of Illinois law that contracts with no termination date can be terminated after a reasonable time by either party.  This will likely have significant impact on similar Illinois contracts used by rail carriers and may also be of interest to those facing this issue in other states.  The decision can be found at http://www.ca5.uscourts.gov/opinions/pub/18/18-11416-CV0.pdf.

 

0 Comments

Leave Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Our Recent Blog Post
  • FRA Publishes Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Revising PTC Systems and Reporting Regulations
  • FRA Publishes Notice of Proposed Rulemaking Requiring Certain Railroads to Develop and Implement a Fatigue Risk Management Program
  • FRA Publishes Amendments Making Qualification and Certification of Engineers Consistent With That of Conductors
  • FRA Publishes Amendments Adopting Waivers Concerning Air Brake Testing, EOT Devices, and Helper Service.
  • Effective January 8, 2021: Revision of Method for Calculating Monetary Threshold for Reporting Rail Equipment Accidents/Incidents
  • Illinois Appellate Court Finds Railroad’s Headquarters Insufficient On Its Own to Establish Illinois as Proper Forum for Occupational Exposure Lawsuit
  • EFFECTIVE OCTOBER 7, 2020: FRA Publishes Final Rule on Rail Integrity and Track Safety Standards
  • Illinois Two-Person Crew Law: Federal Court Declares the Law Preempted – But Throws a Lifeline to the State
  • You May Have More Employees Than You Think—At Least For FELA Purposes
  • At Long Last OSHA Issues Final Rule Exempting Workers From OSHA Regulations
  • United States Supreme Court Expands Protection Based On Sexual Preference And Identity
  • Federal Government Resources
  • Railroad Employer’s COVID-19 Manual
  • Minimizing Liability in Your Team’s Remote Workplace
  • FRA Issues Proposed Rule On Intercity Passenger Performance Measurements

Indiana Court Holds Landowners Must Pay for Private Crossing Maintenance

Previous thumb

To Notarize, Or Not To Notarize — That Is The Question!

Next thumb
Scroll

Fletcher & Sippel LLC
29 North Wacker Dr, Suite 800
Chicago, IL 60606-3208

(312) 252-1500 (Main)
(312) 252-2400 (Fax)

Contact Us



©2019 Fletcher & Sippel LLC.  Branding & Designed by Menagery, Inc.